Vanilla Sky 25th Anniversary Review: Cameron Crowe’s Stunning Mind-Bender Still Fascinates Viewers

Vanilla Sky 25th Anniversary Review: Cameron Crowe’s Stunning Mind-Bender Still Fascinates Viewers Tom Cruise and Penélope Cruz create a romantic version of a lucid dream in Vanilla Sky.

25 years later, there is still plenty to analyze in filmmaker Cameron Crowe’s mind-bending look at life, love, friendship, disfigurement, and near-death experiences, Vanilla Sky.

In 2001, Oprah Winfrey talked to Tom Cruise on her show about his controversial film, Vanilla Sky, and the actor had much to say about the meaning behind this film. Oprah asked him why his successful character, David Aames, gets in the car with Julie Gianni (Cameron Diaz) after finding the love of his life, Sofia (Penélope Cruz). That question will haunt viewers as they watch this confusing at times, but very deep, dramatic movie.

Based on a Spanish language 1997 film, Open Your Eyes, which also starred Cruz, Vanilla Sky reunited Crowe and his Jerry Maguire star, Cruise. Vanilla Sky didn’t fare too well with mainstream audiences, who gave the film a very low CinemaScore mark (“D-“), but the film went on to win many fans over the past two and a half decades.

Vanilla Sky 25th Anniversary Review: Cameron Crowe’s Stunning Mind-Bender Still Fascinates Viewers
Tom Cruise runs through the streets of New York’s Times Square in a stunning opening sequence in Vanilla Sky.

Vanilla Sky opens with David Aames waking up and driving through deserted Manhattan streets. He gets out of his car in Times Square, and runs through the streets in a sequence that is one of the most impressive of all-time. This scene resembles a bad dream, much like many of the sequences in the latter half of the movie.

Cameron Diaz’s Julie is an aspiring singer, who is a sex buddy of David’s. She’s a ticking time bomb, and at a big party, David hides from her with Sofia (Cruz), a woman that David’s best friend, Brian (Jason Lee), has just met.

As David and Sofia start to develop a bond together, the movie creates a beautiful couple of scenes that establish the connection between these two characters. Peter Gabriel’s “Solsbury Hill” plays on the soundtrack as it intensifies the romance between them.

David gets in Julie’s car after meeting with Sofia, and she runs the car off the road. David’s life descends into a living hell as his face is badly disfigured.

Vanilla Sky 25th Anniversary Review: Cameron Crowe’s Stunning Mind-Bender Still Fascinates Viewers
Tom Cruise meets up with Cameron Diaz in a car in a scene from the film ‘Vanilla Sky’, 2001. (Photo by Paramount/Getty Images)

What makes this film so compelling is how David’s life flips upside down. He starts off as a wealthy man who inherited his business from his successful father, and he ultimately suffers the consequences of bad decision-making that helps destroy the relationship he was developing with Sofia.

Or can David get facial reconstruction surgery and salvage that love he has forged with Sofia? Crowe seems to lead us in that direction with some major plot twists that occur in the film.

Each plot development becomes more and more interesting to watch. Benny the Dog, a dog who was frozen and brought back to life, figures into the equation somehow. You’ll be fascinated to see how.

Cruise delivers a strong performance, especially in the earlier stages of the movie.

David and Sofia connect in a way that will make audiences believe in the power of true love and first connections. The dialogue supports their characters’ romantic philosophies. For example, the great line: “Every passing minute is another chance to turn it all around.”

Then, Crowe pulls the rug from underneath the audience. Cruise’s David becomes more and more aggressive as he deals with the horrors of his condition, especially in a great sequence set in a nightclub.

Vanilla Sky 25th Anniversary Review: Cameron Crowe’s Stunning Mind-Bender Still Fascinates Viewers
Penélope Cruz’s Sofia is the object of Tom Cruise’s desires in Vanilla Sky.

This film’s soundtrack is certainly one of its biggest strengths with Joan Osborne’s song, “One of Us,” among the many incorporated into the picture during its most terrifying moments. “Good Vibrations” from the Beach Boys also makes its way into the picture in one of the other disturbing parts of the latter half of the film.

Cruz and Cruise give off the most romantic energy possible in Vanilla Sky. This film wants to make the viewer appreciate the power of genuine love.

Also integrated into the film is Kurt Russell’s McCabe, a psychologist who bonds with David when he finds himself accused of murdering a key character. Russell is impressive in one of the more energetic non-action film performances of his career. He and Cruise also form a memorable bond on-screen.

Crowe put a lot of intelligence into this adaptation of the 1997 material. You can tell which moments are Crowe’s personal touches and which ones are not. It’s a miracle the film was released by Paramount the way that it was, given the sour nature of some of the material.

As characters say in the movie, you can’t have the sweet without the sour, but this film has a lot of sour elements that were most likely the reason some audiences disliked the film when it was originally released.

Vanilla Sky 25th Anniversary Review: Cameron Crowe’s Stunning Mind-Bender Still Fascinates Viewers
Tom Cruise finally meets his chosen moment in the end of Vanilla Sky.

Vanilla Sky could never be a perfect movie. 25 years later, there are still the same minor flaws present. Those problems include the constant and abrupt tone shifts, and the use of the “is it real or is it a dream?” motif once too often.

However, Crowe’s movie has some wonderfully moving scenes. It’s hard not to be caught up in the concept of a lucid dream, which is part of the whole backstory of the film’s plot. Every scene between Cruise and Cruz is purely poetic, and this romance stands the test of time as a great one.

Cameron Diaz’s performance provides the horrific juxtaposition to the sweet and kind Penélope Cruz turn as Sofia.

Vanilla Sky is a well-constructed cinematic achievement, overall, and the film makes one yearn to appreciate the most beautiful moments in life that make it worth living.

“It’s the little things. There’s nothing bigger.”

Vanilla Sky was recently shown in select theaters to honor its 25th anniversary.

Critic Rating:
User Rating:
[Total: 0 Average: 0]

 

Follow us on X and on Instagram!
Like us on Facebook!

Thomas Duffy is a Critics Choice member who has written film reviews for most of his life, starting at age 11 when he crafted his first full length movie critique on the film, "Roxanne," a Cyrano story featuring Steve Martin. As a result of that review and other movie obsessive writing, Thomas was awarded a creative writing award in sixth grade. Thomas is the proud author of nine books, including two highly acclaimed novels, "To Never Know" and "Social Work." Thomas can be found on X (formerly known as Twitter) or at a New York City movie theater watching the latest hit or independent movie. You can also run into him at Tribeca or at the New York Film Festival.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.