Victorian Psycho Review: Not Insane Enough

Victorian Psycho Review: Not Insane Enough Victorian Psycho Ruth Wilson as Mrs. Pounds and Maika Monroe as Winifred Notty in Victorian Psycho (c) Bleecker Street

Victorian Psycho is an all-right horror film. However, it was a better horror comedy, and that is the problem sometimes with adaptations.

A few detail changes can completely create a different tone. The movie plays within the horror comedy world, but still feels too much like a straight horror film. It needed more of the things that made Ms. Notty such a quirky serial killer.

Winifred feels too psychotic in the movie.

Victorian Psycho Review: Not Insane Enough
Ruth Wilson as Mrs. Pounds and Maika Monroe as Winifred Notty in Victorian Psycho (c) Bleecker Street

She needs to feel more like she says, “I am the sanest person I know.” Someone oblivious to their own psychosis. That’s really part of the charm of this story: A woman who does these horrific things but feels they are completely normal.

Victorian Psycho has all the right details and bones of the book, but some things just don’t connect as well as they do in the book. It’s simply a case of the book being better.

As a fan of Virginia Feito’s work, the movie may not live up to expectations.  This is surprising since Feito is credited with writing the screenplay. Maybe the story just exists better in literary form.

However, it’s not a bad horror film by any means. It’s just not a good horror comedy. It’s more straightforward horror.

I laughed so much reading the book, but barely chuckled watching the film version. The shocks and horrors just made me sure to never hire Ms. Notty.

Victorian Psycho Review: Not Insane Enough Victorian Psych
Maika Monroe as Winifred Notty in Victorian Psycho (c) Bleecker Street

That’s a recipe for disaster.

Maika Monroe is great as Winifred. She gives her the right balance of insanity while still showing some humanity.

The big reveal at the end of Victorian Psycho about Winifred’s reasoning and purpose for working at the Pounds house remains the same in the book and movie.

However, the movie puts a greater emphasis on Winifred’s desire for a place to belong. This humanizes her pursuits and actions a lot more than in the book.

The book has more fun with the idea that she just can’t find a place to fit in. The twist of the Pounds family became a lot more obvious in the movie, and it removes some of the humor in this psychotic weird girl just trying to fit into normal society.

Victorian Psycho Review: Not Insane Enough Victorian Psycho
Jacobi Jupe as Andrew Pounds and Evie Templeton as Drusilla Pounds in Victorian Psycho. (c) Bleecker Street

The constant mentions of wanting a family take away some shock value.  The shock value is part of what makes the story so outrageously fun.

This makes the final horrors a little less impactful. Additionally, very small changes end up mattering.

For example, it’s kind of disturbingly funny to know how Winifred and Drusilla spend days with the corpses, and Drusilla proves herself to be a lot more ruthless than her sister.

One of the best lines and moments of the book doesn’t exist in the movie. Winifred saying she was a good governess, the children were just stupid, before killing Mrs. Pound is such a memorable and entertaining moment.

The movie needed it.

Victorian Psycho Review: Not Insane Enough Victorian Psycho
Maika Monroe as Winifred Notty in Victorian Psycho. (c) Bleeker Street

The film’s final moments of Drusilla and Winifred smiling at each other are a nice touch. It shows that, despite the betrayal, they finally found someone who understands them. They finally found true family.

Drusilla and Winifred being kindred spirits is something that is funny in both versions.

A sequel of Winifred and Drusilla’s double act killing spree could have been magical. Maybe murderous sisters can be the topic of Virginia Feito’s next book.

Victorian Psycho is a fun horror film that could have benefited more if it used more elements from the source material.

Victorian Psycho Review: Not Insane Enough Victorian Psycho
Jacobi Jupe as Andrew Pounds in Victorian Psycho. (c) Bleecker Street

It isn’t bad as it is, but it just doesn’t match the level of the source material. Go into the film with no expectations.

If you adore the book, you may be slightly disappointed.

Victorian Psycho is playing at theaters nationwide.

Critic Rating:
User Rating:
[Total: 0 Average: 0]

 

Follow us on X and on Instagram!
Like us on Facebook!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.